Mises and Rothbard On War Finance
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.52195/pm.v2i1.365Abstract
Inside the «economics of war» field of study, very few economists have tried to build a systematic theory of the consequences of the different methods of financing wars. Even fewer economists have ever attempted to elaborate a theory that meets both efficiency and ethical criteria. The first studies in this field can be traced back to the late scholastics. Francisco Suarez (1548-1617) and Francisco de Vitoria (1486-1546) are well known as founders of international law studies. The latter, using his characteristic juridical approach to ethical problems, concludes that the prince can use no neutral person or private property in order to wage a war1.
But it was Juan de Mariana (1536-1623) who first tried to unite the ethical and the economic dimension of war finance. Mariana started by analyzing the question of the resources the prince is allowed to use for waging a war. His answer could be described as a libertarian answer; the king is not the owner of the properties of his subjects, and thus, he cannot dispose of them at his whim but only after having gained the acceptance of the owner. Then he turned to the different financial tools, and he described the economic consequences of their use. After dealing with the effects of taxation, inflation and the king’s credit, he recommended that both the king and the citizens be aware of the ethical and practical point of views2.
After Mariana, very few thinkers have worked on war finance combining both approaches. In this last century the Austrian School of Economics has contributed to the development of the war finance theory by the hand of Ludwig von Mises and Murray N. Rothbard. The first, concentrated his analysis on the possible use of the means to wage a war, and their consequences. On the contrary Rothbard´s approach is known for its focus on the ethical approach to war finance.
References
AUSPITZ, R. and LIEBEN, R. (1889), Untersuchungen über die Theorie des Preises. Leipzig.
BOURNE, R. (1919), Untimely Papers. B.W. Heubsch: New York. MARIANA, J. de (1987), Tratado y discurso de la moneda de Vellón que al presente se labra en Castilla, y de algunos desórdenes y abusos. Originally written in Latin under the title De monetae mutatione and translated by the author. With an introductory study by Lucas Beltrán. Instituto de Estudios Fiscales: Madrid.
MISES, L. v. (1912), Theorie des Geldes und der Umlaufsmittel. Munich.
—(1918), «Über Kriegskostendeckung und Kriegsanleihen». Transcription of a work presented by Mises to a group of officials of the Austrian Army. Phoebus: Wien.
—(1953), The Theory of Money and Credit. Second edition. Translated by H.E. Batson. Yale University Press: Yale.
—(1981), The Theory of Money and Credit. Third edition. Translated by H.E. Batson. Liberty Fund: Indianapolis.
—(1983), Nation, State, and Economy, Contributions to the Politics and History of our Time. Translated by Leland B. Yeager from the original German version. New York University Press: New York.
—(1963), Human Action: A Treatise on Economics. (2nd edition). Yale University Press: New Haven.
—(1978), Notes and Recollections. With a foreword by Margit von Mises. Translated and Postscripted by Hans F. Senn-holz. Libertarian Press: South Holland, Illinois.
—(1998a), Interventionism. Translated from the German manuscript [1940] by Thomas Francis McManus and Heinrich Bund. The Foundation for Economic Education: Irvington-on-Hudson, N.Y.
—(1998b), Human Action, Scholar´s Edition. Auburn, Alabama: Ludwig von Mises Institute. ROTHBARD, M.N. (1950), «The Economics of War». Unpublished manuscript.
—(1982), The Ethics of Liberty. Humanities Press Inc.: Atlantic Highlands, N.J.
—(1963), «War, Peace and the State». The Standard, Vol. II, n. 5, pp. 2-5, 15-16.
—(1993), Man, Economy and State. A Treatise o Economic Principles. Auburn, Ala.: Ludwig von Mises Institute.
—(1970), Power and Market: Government and the Economy. Sheed Andrews and McMeel, Inc.: Kansas City.
—(1990), What has Government Done to Our Money? Lud-wig von Mises Institute, Auburn University: Auburn, Alabama.
—(2004), Man, Economy, and State: A Treatise on Economic Principles with Power and Market: Government and the Economy, Scholar´s Edition. Ludwig von Mises Institute: Auburn, Alabama.
SALERNO, J.T. (1997), «War and the Money Machine: concealing the cost of war beneath the veil of inflation». Published in John V. Denson (editor), The Cost of War; America´s pyrrhic victories. Transaction Publishers: New Jersey.
SUÁREZ, F. (1612), De Legibus ac de Deo Legislatore. Coimbra.
VITORIA, F. de (1991), Political Writings. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
